In the independent medical review workers’ comp in California system, disputes over medical treatment are common. When a treatment request is denied, delayed, or modified by a claims administrator during the utilization review process, an injured worker has the right to challenge that decision through an Independent Medical Review (IMR). This process gives workers an opportunity to have a neutral third-party doctor evaluate the necessity of the requested treatment. For workers pursuing a workers’ compensation claim in Yuba City, CA, knowing how and when to initiate an IMR can make a significant difference in accessing the care they need.

When Is Independent Medical Review Used?

IMR is used when a utilization review (UR) denies or modifies a treatment request made by a treating physician. UR decisions are based on medical necessity as defined by evidence-based guidelines, including the Medical Treatment Utilization Schedule (MTUS). If the UR determines that a proposed treatment is not medically necessary, the worker receives a written denial notice. At this point, the injured worker has the right to request an IMR to challenge the decision.

The IMR process is available only after the UR process has been completed. If the UR fails to act on the request within the specified timeline, the denial is considered invalid, and the worker may have other legal options. But if the UR process was followed correctly, then IMR is the next step for review.

a doctor wearing a medical suit using a clipboard with paper to write notes

How to Initiate the IMR Process

To begin the IMR process, the injured worker must submit a completed IMR application form to the Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC). This form is usually included with the UR denial letter. It must be submitted within 30 days of receiving the written denial or modification notice. If the form is not submitted in time, the right to IMR may be forfeited, and the treatment request will remain denied.

The IMR form asks for basic details such as the worker’s name, claim number, injury description, and details about the disputed treatment. It must be signed and dated before being submitted. The DWC then forwards the case to Maximus Federal Services, the organization contracted to conduct independent medical reviews in California.

a person holding a pen, filling out forms on a wooden table

What Documentation Is Needed?

The review process relies on medical records and supporting documents. The claims administrator and treating physician are both required to submit all relevant medical information related to the treatment request. This includes clinical notes, diagnostic tests, evaluations, and previous treatment history. Workers are not required to submit documents themselves, but they may provide written comments or additional information to support their position.

The reviewing physician will evaluate whether the proposed treatment meets the standards for medical necessity using MTUS guidelines or other recognized medical evidence. The reviewer does not examine the worker in person but relies entirely on the documents submitted. This makes it important that all records are accurate and up to date.

How Are IMR Decisions Made?

Once all documentation is received, the reviewing physician makes a decision within 30 days in most standard cases. The reviewer determines whether the treatment is medically necessary based on evidence-based guidelines. For urgent cases, decisions are issued within three business days. The decision is final and binding on all parties. It cannot be appealed, except in rare cases involving fraud, conflict of interest, or abuse of discretion.

If the IMR approves the treatment, the claims administrator must authorize it promptly. If the treatment is denied again, the injured worker will not receive it through the workers’ compensation system unless the case qualifies for further legal review under a different rule or exception.

a man and a woman exchanging a paramedic bag through an ambulance

Get Legal Support Before and During IMR

The independent medical review workers’ comp California process is an important part of protecting your right to proper medical care after a work injury. Because decisions rely on detailed medical records and precise timing, mistakes or delays can impact your recovery and benefits. Legal assistance can help ensure deadlines are met, paperwork is complete, and treatment is not denied due to administrative errors.

Whether you’re facing a UR denial or preparing for an IMR as part of a  workers’ compensation claim, having a trusted legal resource matters. If you’re seeking guidance from a workers’ comp attorney or representation from a work injury law firm in Glenn, CA, a knowledgeable attorney can help manage your case from start to finish.

The Law Office of Harley Merritt supports injured workers through all stages of the claims process, including utilization review disputes and independent medical reviews. Reach out to the firm to schedule a free consultation and receive help with your IMR or denied treatment issue.

Contact us today.